(More thoughts inspired by Jonah Goldberg's Liberal Fascism)
Hitler's German exceptionalism was similar to Jeremiah Wright's Afrocentrism, which Wright preached for twenty years to the listening and admiring ears of Barack and Michelle Obama. Racial preferences and affirmative action for Germans were ideas Hitler could really get behind. Marxism "both fascinated and repulsed" Hitler, who became "utterly convinced that Marx was the architect of a Jewish plot. World War I led to the enthronement of Lenin in Russia, Mussolini in Italy, and Hitler in Germany." Fighting honorably for a German victory, Hitler was really pissed when "German Reds" demanded peace with Soviet communism. Hitler was in the hospital, recovering from a bout with temporary blindness, "when news of the armistice was announced." Goldberg writes that it was a "transformative event for Hitler," increasing his hatred for the democratic government of Germany, which surrendered. He felt German honor had been betrayed, and he developed a pathological anti-Semitism. His political career was launched."
Hitler resented German elites and particularly Jews, and he came to realize that many others in Germany and central Europe ("particularly Czechoslavakia") thought as he did. What he admired about Mussolini was his "salesmanship." (We have just witnessed Barack Obama doing a masterful job of selling Barack Obama in the election of 2008). Hitler realized he had a chance to become "National socialism's greatest salesman."
This blog is looking for wisdom, to have and to share. It is also looking for other rare character traits like good humor, courage, and honor. It is not an easy road, because all of us fall short. But God is love, forgiveness and grace. Those who believe in Him and repent of their sins have the promise of His Holy Spirit to guide us and show us the Way.
Friday, April 10, 2009
Building a "New State"
(More thoughts inspired by Jonah Goldberg's Liberal Fascisim)
The next "man of the left" in Europe to embrace fascism was Adolf Hitler. "What Hitler got from Italian Fascism was the importance of having an idea that would arouse the masses." ("Hope and Change?") Hitler was willing to say or do anything to achieve and hold onto power. He loved to orate to "massive, exquisitiely staged rallies>" Sound familiar? "Without the loudspeaker, Hitler once observed, we would never have conquered Germany." Without the teleprompter, Obama never would have conquered America.
Hitler had four significant ideas: "power concentrated in himself, hatred - and fear - of Jews, faith in the racial superiority of the German Volk, and, ultimately, war, to demonstrate and secure the other three."
"Nazism and fascism were both popular movements with support from every stratum of society. Corporations in Germany, like their counterparts today, tended to be opportunistic, not ideological."
Goldberg notes that Hitler was "first and foremost a revolutionary." That made him a man of the left. "For conservatives, revolutions are almost always bad - unless as in the case of the United States, you are trying to conserve the victories and legacy of a previous revolution."
Hitler was all about building a "new state." In Mein Kampf he wrote, "Either the German youth will one day create a new state founded on the racial idea, or they will be the last witnesses of the complete breakdown and death of the bourgeois world."
American conservatives, writes Goldberg, "seek to preserve both traditional values and the classical liberal creed enshrined in the Constitution. American conservativism straddles these two distinct but overlapping libertarian and traditionalist strains, whereas Hitler despised both of them."
Hitler was into "identity politics," hating Jews and glorifying blue-eyed blonde Germans. He also suffered from an enormous intellectual inferiority complex. More important, he resented his father for any number of perceived offenses. Women, in his mind, were little more than terrifying syphilis carriers."
The next "man of the left" in Europe to embrace fascism was Adolf Hitler. "What Hitler got from Italian Fascism was the importance of having an idea that would arouse the masses." ("Hope and Change?") Hitler was willing to say or do anything to achieve and hold onto power. He loved to orate to "massive, exquisitiely staged rallies>" Sound familiar? "Without the loudspeaker, Hitler once observed, we would never have conquered Germany." Without the teleprompter, Obama never would have conquered America.
Hitler had four significant ideas: "power concentrated in himself, hatred - and fear - of Jews, faith in the racial superiority of the German Volk, and, ultimately, war, to demonstrate and secure the other three."
"Nazism and fascism were both popular movements with support from every stratum of society. Corporations in Germany, like their counterparts today, tended to be opportunistic, not ideological."
Goldberg notes that Hitler was "first and foremost a revolutionary." That made him a man of the left. "For conservatives, revolutions are almost always bad - unless as in the case of the United States, you are trying to conserve the victories and legacy of a previous revolution."
Hitler was all about building a "new state." In Mein Kampf he wrote, "Either the German youth will one day create a new state founded on the racial idea, or they will be the last witnesses of the complete breakdown and death of the bourgeois world."
American conservatives, writes Goldberg, "seek to preserve both traditional values and the classical liberal creed enshrined in the Constitution. American conservativism straddles these two distinct but overlapping libertarian and traditionalist strains, whereas Hitler despised both of them."
Hitler was into "identity politics," hating Jews and glorifying blue-eyed blonde Germans. He also suffered from an enormous intellectual inferiority complex. More important, he resented his father for any number of perceived offenses. Women, in his mind, were little more than terrifying syphilis carriers."
A Basketball Player, Not a Brawler
(More thoughts inspired by Jonah Goldberg's Liberal Fascism)
Terror became an official government policy in the French Revolution. World War I gave birth to Fascism. Mussolini quit the Socialist Party to become a leader in the pro-war movement. American interventionists such as Woodrow Wilson, John Dewey, and Walter Lippman, like Mussolini, came from leftist perspectives.
Mussolini's thinking had undergone a subtle change. Socialism was predicated on the Marxist view that "workers" as a class were more bound by common interests than nationality. But Mussolini was more interested in creating a national socialism. After being defeated by the Socialist Party in a November election, he moved fascism from socialist to populist. "Direct Democracy and nationalization of industry and banking were two of the main planks of the Fascist agenda. The populists sought to expand the scope of government in order to help the little guy." Sound familiar?
Like Obama, Mussolini was a pragmatist, "constantly willing to throw off dogma, theory, and alliances whenever convenient." (Rev. Wright, Bill Ayres, Tony Rezko: I hardly knew ye!) Like Obama, Mussolini's main governing themes were expediency and opportunism.
So far, though, we have not seen nationalism or thuggish force emphasized by Obama. Mussolini turned to thuggish nationalism with enthusiastic violence. Obama is a basketball player, not a brawler. He seems to enjoy apologizing to the world about America. Mussolini promised to restore pride and order. Obama promises "hope and Change."
After he became prime minister of Italy, Mussolini "never conceded the absolute authority of the state to dictate the course of the economy. He nationalized industry, or "regulated it to the point where the distinction was hardly a difference." This is what Rush Limbaugh so brilliantly has been warning us to watch out for about Obama.
Terror became an official government policy in the French Revolution. World War I gave birth to Fascism. Mussolini quit the Socialist Party to become a leader in the pro-war movement. American interventionists such as Woodrow Wilson, John Dewey, and Walter Lippman, like Mussolini, came from leftist perspectives.
Mussolini's thinking had undergone a subtle change. Socialism was predicated on the Marxist view that "workers" as a class were more bound by common interests than nationality. But Mussolini was more interested in creating a national socialism. After being defeated by the Socialist Party in a November election, he moved fascism from socialist to populist. "Direct Democracy and nationalization of industry and banking were two of the main planks of the Fascist agenda. The populists sought to expand the scope of government in order to help the little guy." Sound familiar?
Like Obama, Mussolini was a pragmatist, "constantly willing to throw off dogma, theory, and alliances whenever convenient." (Rev. Wright, Bill Ayres, Tony Rezko: I hardly knew ye!) Like Obama, Mussolini's main governing themes were expediency and opportunism.
So far, though, we have not seen nationalism or thuggish force emphasized by Obama. Mussolini turned to thuggish nationalism with enthusiastic violence. Obama is a basketball player, not a brawler. He seems to enjoy apologizing to the world about America. Mussolini promised to restore pride and order. Obama promises "hope and Change."
After he became prime minister of Italy, Mussolini "never conceded the absolute authority of the state to dictate the course of the economy. He nationalized industry, or "regulated it to the point where the distinction was hardly a difference." This is what Rush Limbaugh so brilliantly has been warning us to watch out for about Obama.
Faith That Moves Mountains
(More thoughts inspired by reading Jonah Goldberg's Liberal Fascism)
As Mussolini said in an interview in 1932, "It is faith that moves mountains, not reason. Reason is a tool, but it can never be the motive force of the crowd." ("Hope and Change, Hope and Change!") William James wrote that all one needs is "the will to believe." In America in the 2008 election, Barack Obama successfully married James's will to believe with Nietzsche's will to power. Faith moving mountains? I think there was another Man who first taught His disciples about that!
Actually, I believe strongly in encouraging people to stand up to oppressive government rulers. I believe in reminding people of the power of the ballot, and urging them not to forget to vote, when they have a chance to put a stop to oppression.
As Mussolini said in an interview in 1932, "It is faith that moves mountains, not reason. Reason is a tool, but it can never be the motive force of the crowd." ("Hope and Change, Hope and Change!") William James wrote that all one needs is "the will to believe." In America in the 2008 election, Barack Obama successfully married James's will to believe with Nietzsche's will to power. Faith moving mountains? I think there was another Man who first taught His disciples about that!
Actually, I believe strongly in encouraging people to stand up to oppressive government rulers. I believe in reminding people of the power of the ballot, and urging them not to forget to vote, when they have a chance to put a stop to oppression.
Thursday, April 09, 2009
A Powerful and Much Admired Fascist Dictator
(More thoughts and ideas from Jonah Goldberg's Liberal Fascism.)
The Italian Fascist movement was founded in 1919. Jews were actually overrepresented in that movement until they were kicked out in 1938. The father of fascism was Benito Mussolini. Mussolini, at first, had many admirers around the world: Churchill, Einstein, Freud, Will Rogers, the American Legion, Toscanini, Columbia University, and Lowell Thomas are mentioned by Goldberg. But Mussolini's fascism had its critics: Ernest Hemingway and Henry Miller were two.
Mussolini's father, a blacksmith, was an "ardent socialist with an anarchist bent." Benito, at age ten, "led a demonstration against his school for serving bad food." At the age of eighteen he began his career as a "left-wing journalist." His father hated the Catholic Church. Benito did his father proud, when he referred to Jesus as an "ignorant Jew," and he tried to purge Christians from the ranks of Italian Socialism. He "demanded that party members renounce religious marriage, baptism, and all other Christian rituals."
Boasting "169 mistresses over the course of his career, Mussolini was also, by contempory standards, something of a rapist." Goldberg believes that Mussolini, being a sex symbol, "paved the way for the sexual deification of Che Guevara." He also "cultivated an impression of being married to all Italian women." When Italy faced sanctions for its invasion of Ethiopia, Mussolini asked Italians to donate their gold to the state. Millions sent in their wedding rings; 250,000 women in Rome alone!
Mussolini and Lenin were mutual admirers. At one point Mussolini considered "moving to the leftist haven of Vermont, (which fills much the same function today)." He was "astoundingly well read and fluent in socialist theory." He carried a Karl Marx medallion in his pocket.
The Italian Fascist movement was founded in 1919. Jews were actually overrepresented in that movement until they were kicked out in 1938. The father of fascism was Benito Mussolini. Mussolini, at first, had many admirers around the world: Churchill, Einstein, Freud, Will Rogers, the American Legion, Toscanini, Columbia University, and Lowell Thomas are mentioned by Goldberg. But Mussolini's fascism had its critics: Ernest Hemingway and Henry Miller were two.
Mussolini's father, a blacksmith, was an "ardent socialist with an anarchist bent." Benito, at age ten, "led a demonstration against his school for serving bad food." At the age of eighteen he began his career as a "left-wing journalist." His father hated the Catholic Church. Benito did his father proud, when he referred to Jesus as an "ignorant Jew," and he tried to purge Christians from the ranks of Italian Socialism. He "demanded that party members renounce religious marriage, baptism, and all other Christian rituals."
Boasting "169 mistresses over the course of his career, Mussolini was also, by contempory standards, something of a rapist." Goldberg believes that Mussolini, being a sex symbol, "paved the way for the sexual deification of Che Guevara." He also "cultivated an impression of being married to all Italian women." When Italy faced sanctions for its invasion of Ethiopia, Mussolini asked Italians to donate their gold to the state. Millions sent in their wedding rings; 250,000 women in Rome alone!
Mussolini and Lenin were mutual admirers. At one point Mussolini considered "moving to the leftist haven of Vermont, (which fills much the same function today)." He was "astoundingly well read and fluent in socialist theory." He carried a Karl Marx medallion in his pocket.
"A Religion of the State"
Jonah Goldberg alleges in his book Liberal Fascism that "American liberalism is a totalitarian political religion." There is no realm of our lives that is beyond "political significance" to liberals. Goldberg coins the term "totalitarian temptation," by which liberals believe that with "just the right amount of tinkering we can realize the utopian dream of "creating a better world."
Because in America "hostility to big government is central to our national character, our fascism must be nice and for your own good." There has been "an explosion of leftist crusades" in recent years from the war on smoking, obsession with animal rights, to the sanctification of organic foods. "What is fascist is that the individual has no right not to be healthy, and that the state therefore has the obligation to force us to be healthy for our own good."
And, what about environmentalism? "Environmentalism gives license to moral bullying and intrusion." Free speech, too, is under "relentless assault where it matters most - around elections - and it it's being sanctified where it matters least, around strippers' poles and on terrorist web sites. As often is the case with liberal fascism, the effort is very careful to be humane and decent, but it will still result in a kind of benign tyranny where some people get to impose their ideas of goodness and happiness on those who may not share them." The essence of liberal fascism, in Goldberg's thesis, is that it is "a religion of the state."
Because in America "hostility to big government is central to our national character, our fascism must be nice and for your own good." There has been "an explosion of leftist crusades" in recent years from the war on smoking, obsession with animal rights, to the sanctification of organic foods. "What is fascist is that the individual has no right not to be healthy, and that the state therefore has the obligation to force us to be healthy for our own good."
And, what about environmentalism? "Environmentalism gives license to moral bullying and intrusion." Free speech, too, is under "relentless assault where it matters most - around elections - and it it's being sanctified where it matters least, around strippers' poles and on terrorist web sites. As often is the case with liberal fascism, the effort is very careful to be humane and decent, but it will still result in a kind of benign tyranny where some people get to impose their ideas of goodness and happiness on those who may not share them." The essence of liberal fascism, in Goldberg's thesis, is that it is "a religion of the state."
Tuesday, April 07, 2009
Opposites Attract
I have been immensely enjoying reading Jonah Goldberg's important 2007 book entitled, Liberal Fascism. Like I did with Ann Coulter's Guilty and Michael Soussan's Backstabbing for Beginners, I am looking at Goldberg's fascinating insights, and trying to see how they may apply to my own experiences and thoughts. I will be picking out bits and pieces of his book to write about here to try to assess how it applies to what is happening in America today.
Goldberg writes that "one of the great ironies of history is that the more similar two groups are, the greater the potential for them to hate each other." In this regard he cites the Israelies and Palestinians, Greeks and Turks, Indians and Pakistanis, Nazis and Soviet Communists: these pairs understand (or understood) each other very well, "but often hate each other." I guess it's the opposite of the coin that "opposites attract," which I believe is true.
Colleen and I are opposites in many ways, but I think she is happily surprised to realize that I also love all the animals here on the farm. It has been her life-long dream to raise her family on a farm with lots of animals. I was always a city boy, even though I grew up in Sioux City, Iowa.
Goldberg writes that "one of the great ironies of history is that the more similar two groups are, the greater the potential for them to hate each other." In this regard he cites the Israelies and Palestinians, Greeks and Turks, Indians and Pakistanis, Nazis and Soviet Communists: these pairs understand (or understood) each other very well, "but often hate each other." I guess it's the opposite of the coin that "opposites attract," which I believe is true.
Colleen and I are opposites in many ways, but I think she is happily surprised to realize that I also love all the animals here on the farm. It has been her life-long dream to raise her family on a farm with lots of animals. I was always a city boy, even though I grew up in Sioux City, Iowa.
Saturday, April 04, 2009
"Be your own person. Think for yourself. And if you see something rotten, don't be afraid to speak out."
I finally finished Michael Soussan's book about his years working in the Oil for Food program at the UN. The book, Backstabbing for Beginners has a surprise ending, which I will not reveal, but there are lots of other points in his last chapters that I want to highlight.
Soussan writes that it was a mistake for the United States to present the war against Saddam as one waged for "disarmament." The UN charter only authorizes intervention if one nation is attacking another. Soussan's example:
Thus, the U.S. and its allies had to "invade Iraq to prove why it was necessary to invade Iraq." The chief weapons inspector for the UN added, "It is somewhat fascinating to me that you can have 100 percent certainty about the weapons of mass destruction (being in Iraq) and zero percent certainty about where they are."
The truth, of course, was that President Bush wanted to topple the dictator, Saddam Hussein, and end his 24-year reign of brutal suppression of the Iraqi people. He wanted to create a democracy in the Middle East, and make it possible for the people of Iraq to live in freedom.
Back to the Oil for Food program. On January 25, 2004 an article was published in Al-Mada, an independent newspaper in Baghdad, which contained a secret list of 270 bribe-takers from all over the world. Saddam's secret contracts with these 270 bribe-takers enabled him to develop "the biggest operation in modern history for buying loyalty and influence around the world."
Right there on the list was "The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a Syria-based terrorist organization that had claimed responsibility for suicide bombings in Israel." Of course, Saddam himself had been paying $30,000 to $50,000 to families of suicide bombers. Even though this was an American election year, Bush did not make much of an issue about it, and Soussan suspects that some of the players were closely related to the Bush team.
I was saddened to read that although Russia and France were the favored nations receiving Saddam's bribes, American and British oil companies tried to get in on the action, by dealing with Saddam through their offices in France. Chevron, who had a board member named Condoleeza Rice, was one of the U.S. companies buying Iraq's oil, and "allowed kickbacks of more than $20 million dollars to find their way back into Saddam's pocket." Chevron was fined in a U.S. court, after it admitted "it should have known" in 2000 that kickbacks could be going to Saddam. Soussan corrects that statement, writing, "Chevron knew, and the woman who would soon be named secretary of state after serving on the board's policy committee was probably aware of the dirty business as well." The policy committee oversaw areas of potential political concern for the company.
Dick Cheney had been the CEO of Haliburton. Haliburton was not on the list of companies that took bribes, but "Haliburton held stakes in two firms that signed contracts for more than $73 million to provide Iraq with oil industry spare parts. The question is, had the contracts with Saddam included the usual kickbacks?
Now that the Oil for Food program was being looked into by investigators and journalists worldwide, Michael Soussan was glad he had made the decision to leave the UN a year or so earlier. "I was glad I was no longer working for an organization that valued its employees more dearly for their ability to hide their eyes, cover their ears, and shut their mouths in the face of gross incompetence and corruption." He wrote an oped piece which was published March 8, 2004 in the Wall Street Journal. He soon received a phone call from a highly placed secretary at the UN, warning him that "they're going to attack you, Michael. They are asking for your personnel file."
Soussan concludes his book by saying that he still believes in efforts to make the UN more transparent. Now, in his teaching job at NYU's Center for Global Affairs, he encourages his students to "Be your own person. Think for yourself. And if you see something rotten, don't be afraid to speak out."
Soussan writes that it was a mistake for the United States to present the war against Saddam as one waged for "disarmament." The UN charter only authorizes intervention if one nation is attacking another. Soussan's example:
"If the UN Charter were applied domestically - say to a village - then every head of household in that village would have the right to beat his wife (assuming a male dominates the household) and starve the children, and the society would not have the right to intervene. Only if a person attacked another family's house could he be restrained, and even then he might be left in charge - as was the case in 1991, when Saddam was left as the ruler of Iraq."
Thus, the U.S. and its allies had to "invade Iraq to prove why it was necessary to invade Iraq." The chief weapons inspector for the UN added, "It is somewhat fascinating to me that you can have 100 percent certainty about the weapons of mass destruction (being in Iraq) and zero percent certainty about where they are."
The truth, of course, was that President Bush wanted to topple the dictator, Saddam Hussein, and end his 24-year reign of brutal suppression of the Iraqi people. He wanted to create a democracy in the Middle East, and make it possible for the people of Iraq to live in freedom.
Back to the Oil for Food program. On January 25, 2004 an article was published in Al-Mada, an independent newspaper in Baghdad, which contained a secret list of 270 bribe-takers from all over the world. Saddam's secret contracts with these 270 bribe-takers enabled him to develop "the biggest operation in modern history for buying loyalty and influence around the world."
Right there on the list was "The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a Syria-based terrorist organization that had claimed responsibility for suicide bombings in Israel." Of course, Saddam himself had been paying $30,000 to $50,000 to families of suicide bombers. Even though this was an American election year, Bush did not make much of an issue about it, and Soussan suspects that some of the players were closely related to the Bush team.
I was saddened to read that although Russia and France were the favored nations receiving Saddam's bribes, American and British oil companies tried to get in on the action, by dealing with Saddam through their offices in France. Chevron, who had a board member named Condoleeza Rice, was one of the U.S. companies buying Iraq's oil, and "allowed kickbacks of more than $20 million dollars to find their way back into Saddam's pocket." Chevron was fined in a U.S. court, after it admitted "it should have known" in 2000 that kickbacks could be going to Saddam. Soussan corrects that statement, writing, "Chevron knew, and the woman who would soon be named secretary of state after serving on the board's policy committee was probably aware of the dirty business as well." The policy committee oversaw areas of potential political concern for the company.
Dick Cheney had been the CEO of Haliburton. Haliburton was not on the list of companies that took bribes, but "Haliburton held stakes in two firms that signed contracts for more than $73 million to provide Iraq with oil industry spare parts. The question is, had the contracts with Saddam included the usual kickbacks?
Now that the Oil for Food program was being looked into by investigators and journalists worldwide, Michael Soussan was glad he had made the decision to leave the UN a year or so earlier. "I was glad I was no longer working for an organization that valued its employees more dearly for their ability to hide their eyes, cover their ears, and shut their mouths in the face of gross incompetence and corruption." He wrote an oped piece which was published March 8, 2004 in the Wall Street Journal. He soon received a phone call from a highly placed secretary at the UN, warning him that "they're going to attack you, Michael. They are asking for your personnel file."
Soussan concludes his book by saying that he still believes in efforts to make the UN more transparent. Now, in his teaching job at NYU's Center for Global Affairs, he encourages his students to "Be your own person. Think for yourself. And if you see something rotten, don't be afraid to speak out."
Friday, April 03, 2009
Happy Birthday to Jon!
Anger At the Greedy Capitalists
In Dover, New Hampshire, on 9-12-08, Barack Obama said this:
Now that he is president, here is what he is doing: he signed a law raising the tax on tobacco nearly 62 cents per pack of cigarettes! When the federal tax on cigarettes was introduced in 1951, it was 8 cents a pack. Now it is $1.01. This tax, of course, hits hardest Americans with lower than average incomes.
Barack Obama: master of the art of saying one thing, and doing another!
But, who are smokers angry at? Not Barack. No, they vent their anger at the stores who raise the prices on cigarettes to implement the new tax. It's the greedy capitalists, not our beloved president. Tricky Dick had nothing on this guy!
"I can make a firm pledge: Under my plan, no family making less than $250,000 a year will see any form of tax increase. Not your income tax, not your payroll tax, not your capital gains taxes, not any of your taxes. You will not see any of your taxes increase one single dime."
Now that he is president, here is what he is doing: he signed a law raising the tax on tobacco nearly 62 cents per pack of cigarettes! When the federal tax on cigarettes was introduced in 1951, it was 8 cents a pack. Now it is $1.01. This tax, of course, hits hardest Americans with lower than average incomes.
Barack Obama: master of the art of saying one thing, and doing another!
But, who are smokers angry at? Not Barack. No, they vent their anger at the stores who raise the prices on cigarettes to implement the new tax. It's the greedy capitalists, not our beloved president. Tricky Dick had nothing on this guy!
From Capitalism to Socialism to Fascism
I caught a snippet of Glenn Beck's radio program Thursday. Socialism? Glenn says we are already there. Fascism? Glenn says we are headed there "smiley face fascism." He reminded his listeners that Benito Mussolini was extremely popular both in America and in Italy, before he joined forces with Adolf Hitler, and they took their countries from socialism to fascism.
I have checked out Jonah Goldberg's book Liberal Fascism. It appears to be time to move that one up to the top of my reading list.
Glenn Beck was talking about the impending financial collapse long before it happened. Though I wish he would cut down on his use of sarcasm, I have to give him credit for being one of the few pundits to predict accurately the economic calamities that have taken place.
I have checked out Jonah Goldberg's book Liberal Fascism. It appears to be time to move that one up to the top of my reading list.
Glenn Beck was talking about the impending financial collapse long before it happened. Though I wish he would cut down on his use of sarcasm, I have to give him credit for being one of the few pundits to predict accurately the economic calamities that have taken place.
"Civilian Purposes"
The "civilian purposes" of Iraq's nuclear program were clear: massive Israeli civilian casualties! So, the next time you hear the Iranian leaders talk about "civilian purposes," you can know with certainty what they mean: the same as Saddam! Oh, and by the way, we have France's Jacques Chirac to thank for Saddam's nuclear program.
A 1990 report from the International Institute for Strategic Studies concluded, "Had it not been for Desert Storm, Iraq could have accumulated a nuclear stockpile of a dozen or more weapons by the end of the decade."
A 1990 report from the International Institute for Strategic Studies concluded, "Had it not been for Desert Storm, Iraq could have accumulated a nuclear stockpile of a dozen or more weapons by the end of the decade."
Wednesday, April 01, 2009
Survival in a Bureaucracy
It seems to me that the Oil for Food program was really developed as a way to get around the sanctions that the UN had imposed on Iraq after Desert Storm. However, when the UN proposed expanding Oil for Food, Saddam opposed expanding it because he didn't want the food and humanitarian aid. He wanted more industrial projects: trucks, telecom equipment, and industrial machinery.
Michael Soussan chronicles in Backstabbing for Beginners how "Saddam and his cronies were happy to organize parade burials through Baghdad once every couple of months, with little wooden coffins that supposedly contained "children killed by the sanctions," but when it came to actually saving these malnourished kids," Saddam had no interest.
Finally, an inquiry panel headed by former Federal Reserve Chairman, Paul Volcker, began to investigate Oil for Food. "Innocent Until Investigated" was the phrase Soussan used in his book. Of course, the UN authorities knew about Saddam's massive fraud from the beginning. The UN, writes Soussan, "was completely unable to enforce even minimal standards of accountability on its members, staff, and agencies. I tried to explain to the investigators that expecting accountability from the UN system was akin to expecting a blind dog to catch a flying frisbee."
Soussan's job was not to tell the truth. It was to figure out on whose behalf he was supposed to lie! Was it Kofi Annan? Was it Pasha, the Armenian Cypriot who was in charge of Oil for Food, as well as other things at the UN, such as security? Was it the Security Council, "which was itself composed of ambassadors who were lying to each other?" Finally, he realized that his job was "to pretend that there was unity of purpose among the members of the Security Council, the UN Secritariat, and Iraq." Though it was clear to Soussan that the program "ripped off the Iraqi people," his job was to extol the program's humanitarian achievements.
The real work of diplomacy took place at diplomatic cocktail parties. Soussan quotes Adlai Stevenson, "A dipomat's life is made up of three ingredients: protocol, Geritol and alcohol." Alcohol was the truth serum, according to Soussan.
Decisions? "The safest decision for a bureaucrat to make was often no decision at all. If you let them sit long enough, most issues go away all on their own," a high-level UN bureaucrat explained to Soussan at a cocktail party. To avoid personal responsibility (the "buck stopping at your desk"), the best thing to do is call a meeting. The point of a meeting, Soussan writes, "is to spread out responsibility for decisions - or, better, to find a reason why no decision can be made at all."
What about management and authority? A deputy was appointed for the Secretary General, to help with management of programs. Follow the logic of this paragraph: "The deputy would be given responsibility for management, though not the authority to manage. Decisions would remain firmly controlled by Annan's chief of staff. It made perfect sense, and it reflected the core nature of the UN's management culture in that it ensured that the person with responsibility had no authority; and vice versa, it protected the people with authority from having to take responsibility."
As in most (or all?) bureaucracies, "survival was what the game was all about."
Michael Soussan chronicles in Backstabbing for Beginners how "Saddam and his cronies were happy to organize parade burials through Baghdad once every couple of months, with little wooden coffins that supposedly contained "children killed by the sanctions," but when it came to actually saving these malnourished kids," Saddam had no interest.
Finally, an inquiry panel headed by former Federal Reserve Chairman, Paul Volcker, began to investigate Oil for Food. "Innocent Until Investigated" was the phrase Soussan used in his book. Of course, the UN authorities knew about Saddam's massive fraud from the beginning. The UN, writes Soussan, "was completely unable to enforce even minimal standards of accountability on its members, staff, and agencies. I tried to explain to the investigators that expecting accountability from the UN system was akin to expecting a blind dog to catch a flying frisbee."
Soussan's job was not to tell the truth. It was to figure out on whose behalf he was supposed to lie! Was it Kofi Annan? Was it Pasha, the Armenian Cypriot who was in charge of Oil for Food, as well as other things at the UN, such as security? Was it the Security Council, "which was itself composed of ambassadors who were lying to each other?" Finally, he realized that his job was "to pretend that there was unity of purpose among the members of the Security Council, the UN Secritariat, and Iraq." Though it was clear to Soussan that the program "ripped off the Iraqi people," his job was to extol the program's humanitarian achievements.
The real work of diplomacy took place at diplomatic cocktail parties. Soussan quotes Adlai Stevenson, "A dipomat's life is made up of three ingredients: protocol, Geritol and alcohol." Alcohol was the truth serum, according to Soussan.
Decisions? "The safest decision for a bureaucrat to make was often no decision at all. If you let them sit long enough, most issues go away all on their own," a high-level UN bureaucrat explained to Soussan at a cocktail party. To avoid personal responsibility (the "buck stopping at your desk"), the best thing to do is call a meeting. The point of a meeting, Soussan writes, "is to spread out responsibility for decisions - or, better, to find a reason why no decision can be made at all."
What about management and authority? A deputy was appointed for the Secretary General, to help with management of programs. Follow the logic of this paragraph: "The deputy would be given responsibility for management, though not the authority to manage. Decisions would remain firmly controlled by Annan's chief of staff. It made perfect sense, and it reflected the core nature of the UN's management culture in that it ensured that the person with responsibility had no authority; and vice versa, it protected the people with authority from having to take responsibility."
As in most (or all?) bureaucracies, "survival was what the game was all about."
Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Business is Business
Each time Saddam Hussein's thugs would go into a Kurdish village, not only would they raze every building to the ground, but then they would set mines throughout the villages and the surrounding fields "to ensure that farm boys would lose a leg, or worse, as soon as they started cultivating their ancestral land again." So writes Michael Soussan in his book Backstabbing for Beginners, adding that "one of the UN's most useful services to the Kurds involved demining, mine awareness campaigns, and the provision of prosthetic limbs to the injured."
The only security these villagers had was the "no-fly" zone imposed on Saddam by the U.S. and Britain, but which was considered "illegal" by the UN, because it was never approved by the UN Security Council, since Russia refused to vote for it, because their vote had been bought by Saddam, who sold the Russians one-third of his oil at below market prices.
However, the Kurds were also what seems to me to be the ultimate Macchiavellian pragmatists. They allowed Saddam's smuggling operations to pass through their territory, and, in fact, took a healthy cut of the cash. An estimated $13 billion in profits from this smuggling went into the pockets of Saddam Hussein. Fuel went across the border into Turkey, where it was resold; also by pipeline into Syria, and by ships along the Iranian coastline, and by trucks into Jordan.
Senator Carl Levin disclosed the practice in 2005, after receiving E-mails from the Treasury Department. Nevertheless, the Bush administration "ignored the phenomenon (Jordan and Turkey were U.S. allies). Some of that oil even ended up as fuel at U.S. gas pumps, after it was resold on the international market to American oil companies." Soussan asserts that there is "an underworld of international corruption that makes our world economy go around."
This smuggling route was the Kurd's only major source of ready cash - except for the drug trade, specifically heroin, from Iran and Afghanistan, which also passed through Kurdish territory.
The only security these villagers had was the "no-fly" zone imposed on Saddam by the U.S. and Britain, but which was considered "illegal" by the UN, because it was never approved by the UN Security Council, since Russia refused to vote for it, because their vote had been bought by Saddam, who sold the Russians one-third of his oil at below market prices.
However, the Kurds were also what seems to me to be the ultimate Macchiavellian pragmatists. They allowed Saddam's smuggling operations to pass through their territory, and, in fact, took a healthy cut of the cash. An estimated $13 billion in profits from this smuggling went into the pockets of Saddam Hussein. Fuel went across the border into Turkey, where it was resold; also by pipeline into Syria, and by ships along the Iranian coastline, and by trucks into Jordan.
Senator Carl Levin disclosed the practice in 2005, after receiving E-mails from the Treasury Department. Nevertheless, the Bush administration "ignored the phenomenon (Jordan and Turkey were U.S. allies). Some of that oil even ended up as fuel at U.S. gas pumps, after it was resold on the international market to American oil companies." Soussan asserts that there is "an underworld of international corruption that makes our world economy go around."
This smuggling route was the Kurd's only major source of ready cash - except for the drug trade, specifically heroin, from Iran and Afghanistan, which also passed through Kurdish territory.
The Day After A Blizzard Can Be Fun!
"I Gotta Be Me"
Michael Soussan shows us in his excellent book Backstabbing for Beginners "that the people the UN sends into countries like Saddam's Iraq are entirely on their own, with no protection from the UN. This meant they lived in fear just like the rest of the population."
Soussan knew sooner or later he would have to operate as "my own man," as opposed to the "easier, safer route of bureaucratic discipline and inertia." Following his conscience would mean rocking boats. "But (he writes) something in my gut made me want to either yell or throw up." I know that is why I am enjoying his book so much. Having worked in and around bureaucracies from 1970-2007, I was never able to refrain from boat-rocking. Like the song says, "I gotta be me."
Soussan knew sooner or later he would have to operate as "my own man," as opposed to the "easier, safer route of bureaucratic discipline and inertia." Following his conscience would mean rocking boats. "But (he writes) something in my gut made me want to either yell or throw up." I know that is why I am enjoying his book so much. Having worked in and around bureaucracies from 1970-2007, I was never able to refrain from boat-rocking. Like the song says, "I gotta be me."
Saturday, March 28, 2009
You want snow pictures?
After the blizzard of '09
"A breath of fresh air. A smile on people's faces. The absence of fear in their eyes."
"It felt great to be out of Baghdad," writes Michael Soussan, the whistle-blower in the UN's corrupted Oil for Food program, as the UN convoy of ten white SUVs drove north to visit the Kurds. "Away from all the oppresive pictures and statues of Saddam Hussein. Freedom may be a political concept, but it is first and foremost a feeling. A breath of fresh air. A smile on people's faces. The absence of fear in their eyes."
Saddam, of course, massacred as estimated 180,000 Kurds in 1986-1988. Kurds want independence, but the international community seems to regard that as taboo, "because it would upset Turkey, a major NATO ally," writes Soussan.
Saddam, of course, massacred as estimated 180,000 Kurds in 1986-1988. Kurds want independence, but the international community seems to regard that as taboo, "because it would upset Turkey, a major NATO ally," writes Soussan.
How Saddam Ripped Off the UN, with Help From Putin and Many Others
Michael Soussan documents in his excellent book, Backstabbing for Beginners, how Russia was in bed with Saddam Hussein all the way in the corrupt Oil for Food program. Moscow colluded with Baghdad to prevent UN inspectors (for four years) from resuming their work looking for weapons of mass destruction. During that period Iraq sold Russian companies $19.1 billion worth of oil. "Hussein explicitly allocated a third of Iraq's underpriced oil to Russia's political leaders. Only they, or a company they approved of, had a right to purchase the below-market oil and resell it to an actual oil company at a profit," according to whistle blower Soussan.
Remember, the people who were screwed by this arrangement were primarily the people of Iraq, but also the rest of the people of the world. "For the price of $19.1 billion, Saddam Hussein had bought himself Russia's seat on the UN Security Council. It guaranteed that the United States would never again be able to attack Iraq with the approval of the UN. Saddam used the profit to buy (mostly) Russian-or Chinese-made weapons on the black market."
But, what about non-oil humanitarian goods that were supposed to go to the Iraqi people? Saddam got 10-30 percent kickbacks from companies selling goods to Iraq. Saddam set up "payment committees" of three Iraq embassy staffers in each of the following countries: "Russia, Greece, Egypt, Switzerland, Italy, Malasia, Turkey, Austria, Yemen, and Syria. France, and other countries, had other creative solutions to help Saddam keep the bribes out of the international banking system. The Iraqi Embassy staff were then charged with transporting the money to Iraq in red canvas bags that were immune from search by airport authorities. Each diplomatic bag could hold up to $1.5 million in $100 bills. The money would be deposited in Saddam's bank to do with as he pleased, just as in the old days, when there were no sanctions on Iraq."
Remember, the people who were screwed by this arrangement were primarily the people of Iraq, but also the rest of the people of the world. "For the price of $19.1 billion, Saddam Hussein had bought himself Russia's seat on the UN Security Council. It guaranteed that the United States would never again be able to attack Iraq with the approval of the UN. Saddam used the profit to buy (mostly) Russian-or Chinese-made weapons on the black market."
But, what about non-oil humanitarian goods that were supposed to go to the Iraqi people? Saddam got 10-30 percent kickbacks from companies selling goods to Iraq. Saddam set up "payment committees" of three Iraq embassy staffers in each of the following countries: "Russia, Greece, Egypt, Switzerland, Italy, Malasia, Turkey, Austria, Yemen, and Syria. France, and other countries, had other creative solutions to help Saddam keep the bribes out of the international banking system. The Iraqi Embassy staff were then charged with transporting the money to Iraq in red canvas bags that were immune from search by airport authorities. Each diplomatic bag could hold up to $1.5 million in $100 bills. The money would be deposited in Saddam's bank to do with as he pleased, just as in the old days, when there were no sanctions on Iraq."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











