The shoplifting epidemic

In City Journal, Christopher Rufo reports in part,

Today, in some West Coast cities, the Supermarket Sweep isn’t a game show—it’s a dark reality, fueled by addiction, crime, and bad public policy. From Seattle to Los Angeles, a “shoplifting boom” is hitting major retailers, which deal with thousands of thefts, drug overdoses, and assaults each year. Since 2010, thefts increased by 22 percent in Portland, 50 percent in San Francisco, and 61 percent in Los Angeles. In total, California, Oregon, and Washington reported 864,326 thefts to the FBI last year. The real figure is likely much higher, as many retailers have stopped reporting most shoplifting incidents to police.

Drug addiction is driving this shoplifting boom. In recent years, West Coast cities have witnessed an explosion in addiction rates for heroin, fentanyl, and meth; property crime helps feed the habit. According to federal data, adults with substance-abuse disorders make up just 2.6 percent of the total population but 72 percent of all jail inmates sentenced for property crimes. Addicts are 29 times more likely to commit property crimes than the average American. Furthermore, as the Bureau of Justice Statistics found, “[39 percent of jail inmates] held for property offenses said they committed the crime for money for drugs”—the most common single motivation for crime throughout the justice system.

Unfortunately, as West Coast cities grapple with an addiction epidemic, the shoplifting boom has only accelerated because of decriminalization. California's Proposition 47, approved by nearly 60 percent of voters statewide in 2014, reclassified many drug and property felonies as misdemeanors, effectively decriminalizing thefts of $1,000 or less. Many criminals now believe, justifiably, that they can steal with impunity. For example, in San Francisco, police reported 33,000 car break-ins last year; the city now leads the nation in overall property crime. In Portland, a repeat offender nicknamed the “Hamburglar” stole $2,690 worth of meat in one year. He bluntly told police officers: “I know the law. I know the rules. I know what I can and can’t do . . . I’m never going to get over $1,000 at any store.” The Portland Police Department, which doesn’t assign officers to retail theft cases, admits that official statistics vastly underreport actual crime.

Some retailers have adopted a policy of private decriminalization, in many cases prohibiting their security guards from physically apprehending shoplifters. Liability losses, they believe, outweigh property losses. When I asked the manager of Seattle’s 96,000-square-foot Target if employees followed a “no touch, no chase” policy, he responded: “Officially, I can’t tell you our policy, but if you watch our front door for an hour, you’ll see pretty clearly what’s happening.” According to reports, the store likely has ten to 40 “security incidents” a day, including a dramatic incident last year when a drug-frenzied man went on a 15-minute rampage, destroying displays and merchandise, only to walk out the door with duffel bags full of goods. Police never arrived.

...Business groups have started to fight back. In Seattle, an association of downtown retailers has pushed the city to tackle “prolific offenders” who repeatedly rob, steal, and assault innocent people in downtown. Citizens, too, are rebelling against higher prices at the register. In the city’s south end, a disabled veteran made headlines for confronting a habitual shoplifter in a Safeway aisle by blocking the man’s exit with his motorized cart. Such displays of popular frustration should inspire reform, but the shoplifting boom remains a challenge for policymakers. How will progressive cities balance a desire to reduce incarceration rates with a commitment to protect businesses? For now, city leaders refuse to consider how mass decriminalization fuels a breakdown in public order.

Read more here.

Recently I was shopping in a Santa Fe Kroger store. I saw a man take a bundle of clothes hangers off the shelf and put them in his big backpack. I went up to the front counter and told the employee. She called security who got there just after the man walked out the door. No effort was made to go after the shoplifter. I know that Walmart has the same policy of refusing to allow employees to follow shoplifters out into the parking lot.

Wardrobe choices

Go here to see a store video of a woman stealing two boxes of wine. She is wearing no clothing below her waist, except a pair of slippers.

Oh what a tangled web we weave...

When first we practice to deceive. I am watching the self check registers. A woman comes up with her three-year-old child in her cart. As the woman approaches, she announces loudly, "We have to pay for these items." She rings up her cartload and pays for all but one item. She turns to her cart and, realizing I have been watching her the whole time, says out loud, "I don't know if I paid for that item." She brings the receipt to me. I look at it. "No, ma'am, you didn't pay for that. Do you still want it?" "Yes, I do." So she pays for it, and heads for the exit.

That's when I notice our security guy following her. He follows her to the door and then confronts her. He had seen her take wrappings off some toys, stuff the toys in her pocket, then put the wrappings in the trash. With the wrappings off, there would be no bar code to trip the security alarm as she exited.

Police were called and she was issued a ticket for shoplifting. "First offense." I don't believe that; it was the first time she had been caught.

No fear

One of our female employees at work today was yelling, "Sir" repeated to a tall man as he was pushing his cart toward the exit. He pretended not to hear her, but everyone else could hear her fine. She finally caught up to him and asked if he had a receipt for his purchases. He told her that the machine at the self check out area did not give him a receipt. Another female employee heard him say that and told him to wait right there, while she went to check the machine. There was no receipt because he had made no purchases.

Meanwhile the first female subtley moved between him and the door. The second female returned to tell him why there was no receipt. He turned the cart over to the first female and left the store.

I told the first female that I admired her courage in confronting him, and that she did not show any fear. She said, "I'm not afraid of anyone. Fear just gets in your way!" Then she remembered that there is one person she is afraid of, a MMA fighter named Rhonda Rousy.

I told the second female how I admired her fearlessness. She said, "Why be afraid? If he hit me, I would get to go home...with pay!"